Meet an Expert

How to Justify an AI Visibility Budget to Finance

Marketers now put about 24% of search budgets into AI visibility. Here is how to justify that move to finance without inventing an ROI story.

Lior Eldan Lior Eldan
Nov 4, 2026 7 min read Strategy

A marketing lead goes into the quarterly budget review and asks to move a quarter of the search line into work that produces almost no clicks. Finance asks the obvious question: what do we get back? Many teams are having this conversation in 2026, because the average AI visibility budget is now about 24 percent of search and content spend. The figure is real. It proves much less than most budget decks claim.

Key Takeaways

  • The 24 percent figure comes from one agency survey and describes what marketers are doing. On its own, it does not show what your company should spend.
  • AI visibility work behaves like brand media. If you fund it from performance lines and judge it on last-click revenue, it will look like a failure for months even when it is working.
  • The case finance can accept has two parts: a measured revenue baseline you are protecting, and a time-boxed test with leading indicators and a stop condition agreed in advance.

Where the 24 Percent Figure Comes From, and What It Leaves Out

In August 2026, Digiday reported that marketers send about 24 percent of their search or content budgets to AI visibility. The figure comes from a survey by Fractl, a content marketing and digital PR agency. In the same survey, 82 percent of marketers had put at least some budget toward AI visibility, 43 percent were spending more than 20 percent, and 18 percent had allocated nothing.

That spread matters more than the average. A mean of 24 percent covers companies spending nothing and companies spending heavily, so it says little about the right amount for your category or growth stage. The source also matters. An agency that sells this work produced the number, and a CFO will notice that quickly. Answerburst sells this work too, so the same caution applies here.

Use the benchmark to show that your request is normal. Whether the spend pays back is a separate question, and the benchmark cannot answer it.

Why Performance Teams Are Paying for Brand-Shaped Work

The Fractl data also shows who is paying. SEO teams (31 percent) and performance marketing teams (32 percent) put the largest share of their own budgets into AI visibility. Content teams (20 percent) and brand teams (21 percent) put in the least.

There is a reason for this. Performance and SEO teams are the first to see clicks decline. Pew Research Center analysed the browsing data of 900 U.S. adults in March 2025. Users who saw a Google AI summary clicked a traditional search result on 8 percent of visits. Users who did not see one clicked on 15 percent. Links inside the summary itself got clicks on just 1 percent of visits. These teams own the traffic number that is falling, so they own the budget that moves.

The problem is what that budget buys. Getting a brand into AI answers depends on earned coverage, consistent entity data and documentation that models already trust. Models do not read trust from a single score. They read it from how many independent sources agree, and that agreement takes months to build. Money taken from a performance line gets judged on that line’s metrics: cost per acquisition, return on ad spend, last click. Judged that way, the work looks like a failure in its first quarter even when it is going well.

What Can You Actually Measure in the First Two Quarters?

You can measure more than most teams do. Start with Share of Citation: how often each engine names your brand as a source when answering a fixed set of buying questions. Track your position when cited and whether the model describes your product accurately. Track Share of Voice as well, but keep it separate. A brand can be mentioned all over the web and still be close to invisible in AI answers.

Few teams measure this yet. Digiday reported a survey by Scrunch and Scribewise in which about 71 percent of respondents were not tracking share of voice against competitors and 70 percent were not monitoring sentiment toward their brand. Without a baseline, you cannot show finance any change.

Report each engine separately. ChatGPT draws on the open web. Gemini cross-references Search, YouTube and Scholar. Perplexity cites its sources inline. If you blend them into one number, you cannot see which engine is moving or which tactic moved it.

+64%
growth in AI brand presence for NewDay USA, tracked weekly across five engines over six months.See the case study.

The tracking schedule is what matters to finance here. Weekly readings on a fixed set of engines produce a trend line that someone outside marketing can check.

The ROI Case You Should Not Make

The tempting deck goes like this. Multiply projected citations by an assumed click-through rate, apply your conversion rate, and show a revenue figure. Every input in that chain is a guess, and finance will find the weakest one. Many AI answers also produce no visit at all. Pew found that users ended their browsing session on 26 percent of pages with an AI summary, compared with 16 percent of pages without one. When an AI answer does influence a buyer, it often shows up weeks later as a branded search, a direct visit or a prospect on a sales call who says they heard about you from an assistant.

Make two narrower claims instead. The first is defensive. Measure how much pipeline organic search currently brings in from informational and comparison queries, which are the queries most likely to trigger AI summaries. That revenue has already been measured and is now at risk. The reallocation is the cost of protecting it.

The second claim is a test with clear timelines. AEO has two layers, and they move at different speeds. Retrieval presence comes from structured, current content that models fetch live, and it can change within weeks. Training-data presence builds slowly through broad coverage. Tell finance which part of the spend pays back on which timeline.

Finance can approve a measured test with a stop condition. It cannot approve a forecast that nobody is able to audit.

Moving money out of SEO is also optional. Digiday reported that the pet food brand Pawco raised its budget by 10 percent in a single quarter to test LLM discovery. Funding a first test as an addition to the budget can be easier to approve than cutting a line that still delivers.

What to Bring to the Next Budget Meeting

  1. Twelve months of organic-sourced pipeline, split by query type, with the queries that trigger AI Overviews flagged.
  2. A fixed set of real buying questions taken from sales calls and support tickets. Run it across ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity and Grok before you spend anything, and record where your brand appears and what each model says about it.
  3. A proposed amount sized to the revenue you are protecting. Do not size it to the industry average.
  4. A written agreement on which budget line pays for the work and which metrics judge it. If the performance budget pays, agree that the first two quarters will be judged on Share of Citation and accuracy, not on cost per acquisition.
  5. A stop condition. If Share of Citation on your question set has not moved after two quarters, the money goes back.
  6. An “AI assistant” option in the “how did you hear about us” field on your forms and in your sales notes, so you start collecting self-reported attribution now.

Bring these six things and you are asking for an experiment that finance can check, which is much easier to approve than a forecast.

FAQs

Is 24 Percent the Right Share of Search Budget to Move to AI Visibility?

It is an average from one agency survey, reported by Digiday in August 2026, and 18 percent of respondents had allocated nothing. Size your budget to the organic revenue you need to protect and the buying questions you need to win, then adjust it based on what your own tracking shows.

Should AI Visibility Work Come out of the SEO Budget or the Brand Budget?

Either can work if the scorecard matches the work. Most AI visibility work behaves like brand media, so whichever line pays should agree to judge it on Share of Citation, answer accuracy and sentiment during the first two quarters, not on last-click revenue.

How Long Before AI Visibility Spend Shows Results?

Retrieval presence, which comes from structured and current content that models fetch live, can move within weeks. Training-data presence builds through broad coverage across independent sources and takes much longer. Give finance a separate timeline for each.

What Is the Difference Between Share of Citation and Share of Voice?

Share of Citation is how often AI models pull a brand into their answers and name it as a source. Share of Voice is how often a brand is mentioned across the web overall. A brand can have high Share of Voice and almost no Share of Citation, so track them separately.

Lior Eldan

About the author

Lior Eldan

Lior Eldan is the Co-Founder of Moburst and serves as its COO. He works at the intersection of marketing, AI and growth, helping brands' teams adapt to AI-driven discovery and decision-making through data-informed strategy and systems thinking.

Meet the whole team

Ready to make your brand the answer?

Our growth strategists take brands from overlooked to recommended. In one call you will see how the AI engines read your brand today, and leave with your own roadmap to dominate the new era of search.